Start by clarifying requirements and scale, then design a data model that separates metadata (files/folders, users, groups) from permissions, using a closure table or materialized path for efficient inheritance. Discuss how to evaluate permissions at read/write time, and cover trade-offs between precomputed effective permissions and on-the-fly resolution, including caching and consistency.
Pro tip: Emphasize that permission checks must be fast and consistent; propose a hybrid approach where effective permissions are precomputed and cached, but invalidated on ACL changes, and discuss how to handle deep hierarchies without recursive queries.
Ask about scale (number of users, files, groups), read/write patterns, latency requirements, and whether permissions can be changed frequently. Also clarify if there are special cases like public links or temporary access.
Define entities: User, Group, File/Folder (with parent-child relationship), and Permission (subject: user/group, object: file/folder, access level: read/write/own). Use a closure table or materialized path to represent hierarchy for efficient ancestor/descendant queries.
Explain how permissions inherit downward: a permission on a folder applies to all descendants unless overridden. Describe the algorithm to resolve effective permissions for a user on a file: gather all ACL entries from the file up to the root, apply precedence rules (e.g., explicit deny > allow, user > group).
Discuss caching effective permissions per user-file pair, using an LRU cache with invalidation on ACL changes. Consider precomputing permissions for hot files or using a graph database for complex hierarchies. Address consistency trade-offs (e.g., eventual vs strong consistency).
Cover scenarios like moving files/folders (recompute permissions), group membership changes, and permission conflicts. Discuss trade-offs between storage overhead, query complexity, and update latency.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
I went relational first because the ACL and membership data is inherently tabular and you want transactions.
Start by clarifying the specific system or feature (e.g., Snapchat's messaging, Stories, or friend graph) and its access patterns, scale, and consistency needs. Then compare relational, graph, and document databases against those requirements, highlighting trade-offs and justifying a primary choice with possible polyglot persistence.
Pro tip: Acknowledge that real-world systems often use multiple databases (polyglot persistence) and that the choice depends on the dominant access pattern—don't force a single database to do everything.
Ask questions to understand the system's data model, read/write patterns, scale, consistency requirements, and latency needs. This ensures your answer is tailored to Snapchat's specific context.
Briefly describe relational, graph, and document databases in terms of their core strengths: relational for structured data and complex joins, graph for highly connected data, document for flexible schemas and horizontal scaling.
For each database type, discuss how it handles the use case's key requirements (e.g., scalability, consistency, query flexibility) and the associated trade-offs (e.g., eventual consistency vs. strong consistency, join performance vs. denormalization).
Choose a primary database (or combination) that best fits the dominant access patterns, and justify why it's optimal. Mention any complementary databases for secondary needs.
Recap the key reasons for your choice and acknowledge any potential drawbacks or mitigations, showing balanced judgment.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
The naive answer is: collect all groups user X belongs to, walk up the folder tree from Y, check ACL entries at each level.
Start by clarifying the requirements: expected query volume, latency, consistency needs, and permission model complexity. Then propose a hybrid solution: precompute and cache effective permissions using a graph traversal (e.g., DFS/BFS) over folder hierarchy and group memberships, and use an inverted index or materialized view for fast lookups. Discuss trade-offs between precomputation (fast reads, slower writes) and on-the-fly checks (slower reads, simpler writes).
Pro tip: Mention that you would use a bitmask or Bloom filter for quick negative checks to avoid expensive traversals, and highlight the importance of cache invalidation strategies when permissions change.
Ask about scale (QPS, number of users/resources), latency SLA, consistency requirements, and permission model (read/write, inheritance rules).
Represent folders as a tree and groups as a DAG; user access is the union of direct, inherited, and group-based permissions.
Decide between on-the-fly traversal (e.g., DFS up the folder tree and through groups) and precomputed materialized permissions. Consider hybrid: cache effective permissions per user-resource pair.
Use caching (e.g., Redis) with TTL or event-based invalidation, bitmasks for permission sets, and indexing for group memberships. For negative checks, use Bloom filters.
Discuss how to handle permission changes: invalidate affected cache entries, use versioning, or recompute asynchronously. Mention eventual consistency trade-offs.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
Caching felt straightforward: cache resolved permissions keyed by user+resource, invalidate on any ACL or group membership change.
Start by clarifying the access control system's scale and requirements, then address each concern (caching, audit logging, admin APIs) in turn, explaining trade-offs and how they integrate. Emphasize security, performance, and maintainability, and tie your choices back to Snapchat's high-traffic, low-latency environment.
Pro tip: Mention that audit logs should be immutable and stored separately from the main database to prevent tampering, and that caching authorization decisions must include a robust invalidation strategy to avoid stale permissions.
Ask about scale (QPS, number of users/roles), latency requirements, consistency needs, and compliance requirements. This ensures your design aligns with Snapchat's expectations.
Propose caching authorization decisions (e.g., in Redis) with appropriate TTL and invalidation on permission changes. Discuss cache key design, eviction policies, and fallback to source of truth.
Outline a system that logs all access control changes and access attempts asynchronously to a durable, append-only store (e.g., Kafka + S3). Ensure logs are immutable, tamper-evident, and include necessary context.
Define RESTful or gRPC endpoints for managing roles, permissions, and policies. Include authentication, authorization (admin-only), rate limiting, input validation, and idempotency.
Explain how caching, logging, and admin APIs interact (e.g., admin changes trigger cache invalidation and audit events). Discuss consistency vs. availability trade-offs and failure modes.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.