← Circle Interview Insights

Circle·Software Engineer·Online Assessment (OA)·Intermediate

Intermediate
May 2026

Summary

Circle OA for a Software Engineer role, one problem, multi-level CRUD design with some sneaky edge cases baked in. The kind of thing that looks like a warmup until you actually read the update rules.

Questions Asked (1)

Q1

Design a Recipe Storage system supporting Create, Read, Update, and Delete operations. Each recipe has a name, ingredients list, and steps list. Add returns an auto-incrementing string ID. Name matching on Add is case-insensitive and duplicates are rejected. Update only succeeds if the new name matches the stored name case-insensitively (no actual renames allowed). All operations return a success or failure indicator.

System DesignAlgorithms & Data StructuresData Modeling
Author's notes

The Add and Delete parts were fine.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Start by clarifying requirements and constraints, then propose a data model using a hash map for O(1) lookups and a counter for auto-incrementing IDs. Walk through each operation, highlighting edge cases like case-insensitive name matching and duplicate rejection, and discuss trade-offs between simplicity and scalability.

Pro tip: Emphasize that Update's case-insensitive name check prevents renames, so you should treat the name as an immutable key; this shows attention to detail and avoids a common pitfall.

1. Clarify Requirements and Constraints

Ask questions to confirm expected scale, concurrency needs, and whether persistence is required. Clarify that ID is a string but auto-incrementing, and that all operations return success/failure.

2. Design Data Model

Propose a Recipe class/struct with id, name, ingredients, and steps. Use a hash map (dictionary) to store recipes by ID for O(1) access, and a separate map from lowercase name to ID for case-insensitive uniqueness checks.

3. Implement CRUD Operations

For Add: check name uniqueness case-insensitively, generate ID, store recipe. For Read: lookup by ID. For Update: verify ID exists and new name matches stored name case-insensitively, then update other fields. For Delete: remove from both maps.

4. Handle Edge Cases and Errors

Address duplicate names on Add, non-existent IDs on Read/Update/Delete, and name mismatch on Update. Ensure all operations return a clear success/failure indicator.

5. Discuss Scalability and Trade-offs

Mention potential improvements like using a database for persistence, handling concurrent access with locks, and sharding for large-scale systems. Compare with alternative data structures.

Key Points to Mention

  • Use of a hash map for O(1) average-time lookups by ID and a secondary map for case-insensitive name uniqueness.
  • Auto-incrementing ID generation: maintain a counter and convert to string, ensuring thread-safety if needed.
  • Case-insensitive name matching: normalize names to lowercase for comparisons and storage in the name index.
  • Update semantics: name is immutable; only other fields can be updated, and the provided name must match case-insensitively.
  • Error handling: return success/failure for each operation, with appropriate error messages or codes.
  • Scalability considerations: persistence, concurrency, and potential use of a database with unique constraints.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.