← Jane Street Interview Insights

Jane Street·Software Engineer·Technical Phone Screen·Intermediate

IntermediatePrefer not to say
May 2026

Summary

Jane Street SWE interview focused entirely on a two-part system design problem around extending a trade tracking class. The problem kept building on itself and required reasoning through correctness without running any code, which was a different kind of pressure than I expected.

Questions Asked (2)

Q1

You have a Table class that tracks trades and their PnL values over time. It supports adding trades, grouping them via filters, and rendering an aggregated PnL view. How would you redesign view_result() to run in O(1) time by maintaining incremental state, while also correctly handling set_global_filter() which can change the active set of trades at any point?

System DesignAlgorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

This took me a while to even frame correctly.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Start by clarifying the current O(N) bottleneck in view_result() and the semantics of set_global_filter(). Then propose maintaining incremental aggregates (e.g., total PnL, count) as trades are added, and for filter changes, either recompute from scratch if filters change infrequently, or maintain per-filter aggregates if they change often. Discuss trade-offs and ensure correctness when filters change.

Pro tip: Emphasize that O(1) view_result() is only possible if you accept O(N) or O(K) cost when the filter changes, and that the right choice depends on the expected frequency of filter changes versus view calls. This shows you understand real-world trade-offs.

1. Clarify requirements and constraints

Ask about the frequency of view_result() calls versus set_global_filter() calls, and whether filters can be combined or are mutually exclusive. This determines the optimal strategy.

2. Design incremental state for trade additions

Maintain running aggregates (e.g., total PnL, count) that are updated in O(1) when a trade is added. Ensure the aggregates reflect the current active filter.

3. Handle filter changes efficiently

If filters change rarely, recompute aggregates in O(N) on filter change. If filters change often, maintain a map from filter to aggregate, updating all relevant aggregates on trade addition (O(K) where K is number of filters).

4. Ensure correctness and thread safety

Verify that aggregates are consistent with the active filter after any operation. If concurrent access is possible, use locks or atomic operations to protect the state.

5. Discuss trade-offs and alternatives

Compare the two approaches (recompute on filter change vs. maintain per-filter aggregates) in terms of time and space complexity, and suggest choosing based on expected usage patterns.

Key Points to Mention

  • Incremental aggregation: update running totals when trades are added, not when view_result() is called.
  • Filter change cost: O(N) recomputation if filters change infrequently, or O(K) per trade addition if filters change frequently.
  • Data structures: use a map from filter ID to aggregate, or a single aggregate plus a dirty flag.
  • Correctness: ensure that the aggregate always reflects the current filter, and handle edge cases like empty filters.
  • Trade-offs: time vs. space, and the importance of profiling to choose the right approach.
  • Thread safety: consider synchronization if the Table is accessed concurrently.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.

Q2

Now assume get_pnl is asynchronous and you want to avoid calling it multiple times for the same trade and time pair. How do you cache these results as class state, and how does that cache interact with set_global_filter() changes, specifically around invalidation and recomputation?

System DesignAPI & IntegrationsTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

The async angle made this feel like a different problem even though structurally it builds on part one.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Start by defining a cache keyed by (trade_id, timestamp) that stores the Future or result of get_pnl, ensuring concurrent calls share the same in-flight request. Then explain that set_global_filter() changes the computation context, so the cache must be invalidated or versioned to avoid returning stale results. Finally, discuss trade-offs between simplicity (clear cache on filter change) and performance (selective invalidation or versioned keys).

Pro tip: Mention that you would use a versioned cache key incorporating the global filter state, so you can keep old results for other filters and avoid a full flush. This shows you think about both correctness and efficiency in a high-frequency trading context.

1. Design the cache structure

Choose a dictionary keyed by (trade_id, timestamp) that stores either the computed PnL or a Future to deduplicate concurrent requests. Ensure thread-safety with locks or concurrent data structures.

2. Handle asynchronous computation

When a request misses the cache, initiate the async get_pnl call and store the Future immediately so other callers await the same result. Use asyncio locks or similar to prevent duplicate calls.

3. Integrate global filter changes

Decide on an invalidation strategy: either clear the entire cache when set_global_filter() is called, or version the cache key with the filter state to allow selective reuse.

4. Discuss invalidation and recomputation trade-offs

Compare full invalidation (simple, correct, but may cause recomputation storms) versus versioned keys (more complex, but preserves cache hits for unchanged filters). Mention memory and latency implications.

5. Address concurrency and consistency

Explain how to handle in-flight requests when the filter changes: either cancel them, let them complete but tag results with the old filter version, or use a generation counter to ignore stale completions.

Key Points to Mention

  • Cache key design: (trade_id, timestamp) plus optional filter version
  • Deduplication of concurrent async calls using Futures or promises
  • Thread-safety and async-safety with locks or atomic operations
  • Invalidation strategies: full clear vs. versioned keys vs. selective eviction
  • Impact of filter changes on in-flight requests and how to handle them
  • Memory management and cache eviction policies (e.g., LRU) for long-running processes

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.