← Instacart Interview Insights

Instacart·Data Scientist·Technical Phone Screen·Intermediate

Intermediate
Apr 2026

Summary

Interviewed for a Data Scientist role at Instacart and got hit with a combinatorics/optimization problem that felt more like a competitive programming challenge than anything I'd call typical DS work. One question, but it had a lot of depth to unpack.

Questions Asked (1)

Q1

You have a set of products that all need to be purchased, and a list of shoppers each covering some subset of those products. What is the minimum number of shoppers needed so their combined purchases cover every product? Return -1 if it's not possible.

Algorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

This is set cover, which I recognized pretty quickly, but then I froze a bit because set cover is NP-hard and I wasn't sure how far they wanted me to go.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Model the problem as a set cover problem where products are elements and shoppers are sets. Since set cover is NP-hard, discuss both exact solutions (e.g., integer programming or branch-and-bound) for small inputs and approximation algorithms (e.g., greedy) for large-scale scenarios, emphasizing the trade-off between optimality and efficiency.

Pro tip: Acknowledge the NP-hardness upfront and propose a practical approach: use the greedy algorithm for a quick approximation, but if optimality is required, suggest formulating as an integer program and solving with a solver like OR-Tools, noting that this may not scale.

1. Clarify the problem and constraints

Confirm that each product must be covered by at least one selected shopper, and that shoppers can be selected multiple times? (No, each shopper can be used at most once). Ask about input size, whether shoppers have costs, and if there are any additional constraints.

2. Formalize as a set cover problem

Define the universe as the set of products and each shopper as a subset of products they can purchase. The goal is to find the minimum number of subsets whose union equals the universe.

3. Discuss computational complexity

Explain that set cover is NP-hard, so no polynomial-time algorithm is known for the optimal solution. This implies that for large instances, we must rely on heuristics or approximations.

4. Propose solution approaches

For exact solutions, suggest integer programming or branch-and-bound, suitable for small inputs. For larger inputs, describe the greedy algorithm: repeatedly pick the shopper covering the most uncovered products, which gives a logarithmic approximation factor.

5. Address feasibility and return -1

Check if the union of all shoppers covers all products. If not, return -1. Otherwise, proceed with the chosen algorithm to find the minimum number.

Key Points to Mention

  • Set cover problem and its NP-hardness
  • Greedy approximation algorithm with O(log n) approximation ratio
  • Integer programming formulation for exact solution
  • Feasibility check: union of all shoppers must cover all products
  • Trade-off between optimality and computational efficiency
  • Potential use of heuristics like genetic algorithms or simulated annealing for large instances

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.