I went with an adjacency list and DFS-based cycle detection on every add_edge call.
Start by clarifying requirements and then propose an adjacency list representation with a topological ordering (e.g., Kahn's algorithm) to detect cycles on edge insertion. Explain that adding an edge (u, v) is safe only if u is not reachable from v; otherwise, it would create a cycle. Walk through the algorithm step-by-step, analyze time/space complexity, and discuss trade-offs with alternative approaches like DFS-based detection.
Pro tip: Mention that you can maintain a topological order incrementally and only recompute when necessary, or use a dynamic topological sort algorithm to achieve better than O(V+E) per edge in practice. This shows you think about performance beyond the naive solution.
Ask about expected graph size, frequency of operations, and whether nodes/edges can be removed. This determines the best data structure and algorithm.
Propose an adjacency list (e.g., HashMap<Node, List<Node>>) for sparse graphs, and mention that you also maintain in-degree counts or a topological order for cycle detection.
Describe that before adding edge (u, v), you check if v can reach u. If yes, reject; otherwise, add the edge and update the topological order or in-degrees.
Walk through Kahn's algorithm: compute in-degrees, perform BFS, and if all nodes are visited, no cycle. For incremental, maintain a topological order and update it when adding edges.
State that naive cycle detection is O(V+E) per edge insertion. Discuss alternatives like dynamic topological sort (O(sqrt(V)) per edge) or DFS with coloring, and their trade-offs.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.