← IMC Interview InsightsSoftware Engineer

IMC·Software Engineer·Technical Phone Screen·Intermediate

Intermediate
Jun 2026

Summary

IMC quant engineer interview with a graph theory true/false question that's sneakier than it looks on the surface.

Questions Asked (1)

Q1

True or false: an acyclic undirected graph with N nodes has at most N-1 edges. Explain your reasoning.

Algorithms & Data Structures
Author's notes

My first instinct was 'true, that's just a tree' and I almost stopped there.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

State that the statement is true, then justify it by connecting acyclic undirected graphs to forests and using the tree edge bound. Explain that any forest with N nodes and k components has exactly N - k edges, so the maximum is N - 1 when it is a single tree.

Pro tip: Mention that the bound is tight: a tree (connected acyclic graph) achieves exactly N - 1 edges, so the statement is true but not strict. Also note that if the graph is disconnected, it has even fewer edges, which reinforces the upper bound.

1. Clarify definitions

Define an acyclic undirected graph as a forest (a disjoint union of trees) and recall that a tree with m nodes has exactly m - 1 edges.

2. Decompose into components

Let the forest have k connected components with sizes n1, n2, ..., nk, where sum(ni) = N. Each component is a tree, so it has ni - 1 edges.

3. Sum the edges

Total edges = sum(ni - 1) = N - k. Since k >= 1, the maximum number of edges is N - 1, achieved when k = 1 (a single tree).

4. Conclude and address tightness

Therefore, an acyclic undirected graph with N nodes has at most N - 1 edges. The bound is tight: a tree with N nodes has exactly N - 1 edges.

Key Points to Mention

  • Acyclic undirected graph is a forest (collection of trees).
  • A tree with m nodes has exactly m - 1 edges.
  • For a forest with N nodes and k components, edges = N - k.
  • Since k >= 1, edges <= N - 1.
  • The bound is tight: a tree (k = 1) achieves N - 1 edges.
  • If the graph is disconnected (k > 1), it has fewer than N - 1 edges.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.