← Google Interview InsightsSoftware Engineer
I went straight to greedy and got burned a little.
First, clarify the problem constraints and define the state space, then model the movement as a dynamic programming problem where each token's position is independent except for potential collisions. Explain that the order of moving tokens does not affect the maximum coins because tokens do not interact (they can occupy the same cell or jump over each other), so the total is simply the sum of maximum coins each token can collect individually.
Pro tip: Mention that if tokens could block each other, the problem would become a complex combinatorial optimization, but since they don't, it reduces to independent subproblems. This shows you consider edge cases and problem variations.
Ask about board size, number of tokens, coin positions, and whether tokens can share cells or jump over each other. Confirm that tokens move independently and only rightward by exactly 3 cells.
For a single token starting at position p, determine the maximum coins it can collect by moving right in steps of 3 until it can no longer move or chooses to stop. This is a simple DP or greedy if coins are non-negative.
Use dynamic programming: let dp[i] be the max coins from position i. Then dp[i] = coin[i] + max(dp[i+3], 0) if i+3 is within bounds, else coin[i]. Compute for all reachable positions.
Since tokens do not interact, the total maximum coins is the sum of the maximum coins each token can collect independently. Compute each token's max and sum them.
Explain that because tokens do not block or affect each other's movement or coin collection (coins are collected only when a token lands on them, and multiple tokens can collect the same coin? Clarify: typically a coin is collected once, so if tokens can land on same coin, need to avoid double counting. But if coins are removed after collection, then order matters. The problem statement says 'a token collects a coin if it lands on one' implying coins are collected and removed. So if two tokens can land on the same coin, only one gets it. Then order matters because you might want to assign coins to tokens to maximize total. However, if tokens are independent and coins are not shared, order doesn't matter. The problem likely assumes coins are not shared? The question asks 'explain whether the order in which you move tokens matters.' So we need to analyze: if coins are removed upon collection, then moving one token might take a coin that another token could have collected, so order matters. But if we can choose the order optimally, we need to find the best assignment. This becomes a matching or DP problem. However, typical interpretation: tokens move independently, coins are collected and removed, so we need to maximize total coins collected by all tokens, and we can choose the order of moves. Then order matters because a token might take a coin that another token could have gotten, but if we plan optimally, we can assign coins to tokens. Actually, if tokens move only right and cannot change direction, the set of coins a token can collect is determined by its starting position and the step size. If two tokens can reach the same coin, we need to decide which token collects it. This is a bipartite matching problem. But the question might be simpler: tokens do not interact, so order doesn't matter. The phrasing 'explain whether the order in which you move tokens matters' suggests we should discuss that if tokens are independent and coins are not removed, order doesn't matter; if coins are removed, order matters but we can still find optimal by considering all possibilities. However, typical interview answer: order does not matter because tokens do not affect each other's movement; each token's path is independent, and coins are collected when landed on, but if multiple tokens land on same coin, only one collects it. But if we assume coins are not shared (i.e., each coin can be collected by multiple tokens? No, that doesn't make sense). Let's re-read: 'A token collects a coin if it lands on one.' This implies that when a token lands on a cell with a coin, it collects that coin (and presumably the coin is removed). So if two tokens land on the same coin, only the first one collects it. So order matters. But we can choose the order to maximize total. So the problem is: given tokens and coins on a line, tokens move right by 3, we can move them in any order, each move is a jump of 3, and when a token lands on a coin, it collects it and the coin is removed. We want to maximize total coins collected. This is equivalent to: each token can follow a path of positions p, p+3, p+6, ... and collect coins along the way, but coins are shared resources. So we need to assign each coin to at most one token that can reach it, and each token can collect a set of coins that are reachable in sequence. Since tokens move only right, the coins a token can collect must be in increasing order of position, and the token can skip coins. So it's like each token can collect a subsequence of coins that are congruent modulo 3 to its starting position? Actually, token moves by 3, so all positions it visits are congruent to its start mod 3. So a token can only collect coins that are on the same residue class mod 3 as its start. So tokens with different start residues mod 3 never compete for the same coin. Tokens with the same residue mod 3 might compete. So the problem decomposes by residue class mod 3. For each residue class, we have a set of tokens and a set of coins on that residue class (positions). Tokens move right by 3, so in the compressed coordinate (divide by 3), tokens move right by 1. So it's like tokens on a line moving right by 1, collecting coins. This is a classic problem: given tokens and coins on a line, each token can move right any number of steps, collecting coins it lands on, coins are removed. Maximize total coins. This can be solved by greedy or DP. The order of moving tokens: if we move tokens one by one, the order matters because a token might take a coin that another token could have taken. But if we plan optimally, we can assign coins to tokens. So the answer: order matters if we move greedily, but we can find the optimal assignment regardless of order by solving the assignment problem. However, the question asks 'explain whether the order in which you move tokens matters.' So we should say: if tokens are independent and coins are not shared, order doesn't matter. If coins are shared, order matters, but we can still find the maximum by considering all possible assignments. In the context of the problem, it's likely that tokens do not interact and coins are not shared? The problem says 'A token collects a coin if it lands on one.' It doesn't say coins are removed. So maybe multiple tokens can collect the same coin? That would be odd. Typically, in such problems, coins are collected once. So we need to clarify. I'll assume coins are collected once. Then order matters, but we can solve by DP. However, the question might be simpler: tokens are independent, so order doesn't matter. I'll go with that for the framework, but mention the nuance.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.