← OpenAI Interview Insights

OpenAI·AI Engineer·Technical Phone Screen·Senior

SeniorPrefer not to say
Apr 2026Remote

Summary

OpenAI AI Engineer interview with a pretty brutal multi-part coding problem centered on matrix multiplication and autograd. Four parts, escalating difficulty, and the last one on parallel prefix scan was not something I had mentally prepared for.

Questions Asked (4)

Q1

Implement an in-place matrix multiplication routine for a chain of square matrices, then explain why it breaks backpropagation.

Technical Trade-offsAlgorithms & Data Structures
Author's notes

The implementation part was fine, pretty mechanical.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

First, clarify the problem: in-place multiplication of a chain of square matrices means overwriting one of the input matrices to store the result, which saves memory but destroys the original data. Then, implement the routine using a temporary buffer or clever index swapping, and explain that backpropagation requires the original matrices to compute gradients, so in-place operations break the computational graph.

Pro tip: Mention that frameworks like PyTorch and TensorFlow explicitly disallow in-place operations on tensors that require gradients, and suggest using out-of-place operations or checkpointing to trade memory for correctness.

1. Clarify the problem and constraints

Restate the question: implement in-place multiplication for a chain of square matrices (e.g., A = A * B * C) without allocating new memory for the result. Discuss the trade-off between memory efficiency and data preservation.

2. Design the in-place algorithm

For a chain of two matrices, use a temporary variable per element or block-wise multiplication to avoid overwriting needed values. For longer chains, multiply sequentially, overwriting one matrix at a time, but note that this still requires temporary storage for the intermediate product.

3. Implement the routine

Write pseudocode or actual code (e.g., in Python/NumPy) that performs the multiplication in-place. Highlight that true in-place matrix multiplication is not possible without additional memory because each output element depends on multiple input elements.

4. Explain backpropagation breakage

Describe how backpropagation computes gradients using the chain rule, requiring the original forward-pass values (e.g., inputs to each multiplication). In-place operations overwrite these values, so gradients cannot be computed correctly.

5. Discuss solutions and trade-offs

Propose alternatives: out-of-place operations, gradient checkpointing, or custom autograd functions that save necessary tensors. Emphasize that memory savings from in-place ops come at the cost of losing gradient information.

Key Points to Mention

  • In-place operations save memory but destroy original data needed for gradient computation.
  • Backpropagation requires the forward-pass activations (inputs to each operation) to compute gradients.
  • Matrix multiplication is not truly in-place without additional memory because each output element depends on multiple input elements.
  • Frameworks like PyTorch raise errors when in-place operations are applied to tensors that require gradients.
  • Alternatives: out-of-place operations, gradient checkpointing, or custom autograd functions.
  • Trade-off: memory efficiency vs. correctness of gradients in training deep networks.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.

Q2

Rewrite the matrix multiplication chain as an out-of-place operation that is compatible with automatic differentiation.

Algorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

Straightforward once you've done the first part.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Start by explaining why in-place operations break automatic differentiation due to aliasing and mutation of tensors needed for gradient computation. Then describe how to rewrite the chain using out-of-place operations, such as creating new tensors for each intermediate result and using functional APIs. Finally, discuss the trade-offs in memory and performance, and how frameworks like PyTorch handle this.

Pro tip: Mention that using out-of-place operations is not just about correctness but also about enabling higher-order gradients and avoiding subtle bugs in complex models. Also, note that some frameworks provide functional variants (e.g., torch.matmul) that are inherently out-of-place.

1. Identify in-place operations

Locate any operations that modify tensors in place, such as add_, mul_, or direct assignment to tensor slices, which can interfere with gradient tracking.

2. Replace with out-of-place equivalents

Rewrite each in-place operation using its out-of-place counterpart, e.g., use torch.add instead of add_, and assign the result to a new variable.

3. Ensure proper graph construction

Verify that the new operations build a clean computational graph without shared references that could cause incorrect gradients.

4. Consider memory and performance trade-offs

Acknowledge that out-of-place operations increase memory usage but are necessary for autograd; discuss potential optimizations like checkpointing or in-place where safe.

Key Points to Mention

  • Autograd requires the original values of tensors to compute gradients, so in-place operations can corrupt saved tensors.
  • Out-of-place operations create new tensors, preserving the computational graph and enabling correct backpropagation.
  • Use functional APIs (e.g., torch.matmul, torch.add) instead of methods that modify in place.
  • Be aware of version counters in PyTorch that detect in-place modifications and may throw errors during backward pass.
  • Trade-offs: increased memory consumption vs. correctness and flexibility for higher-order derivatives.
  • Some operations can be safely done in-place if they don't affect tensors needed for gradient computation, but it's safer to avoid them in autograd contexts.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.

Q3

Manually implement the backward pass for the matrix multiplication chain without relying on any autograd framework.

Algorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

This is where I slowed down.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

First, clarify the problem: implement forward and backward passes for a chain of matrix multiplications (e.g., Y = A @ B @ C) without autograd. Then derive the gradients manually using the chain rule and matrix calculus, and present a clean, vectorized implementation with careful attention to shapes and efficiency.

Pro tip: Emphasize that you would verify your manual gradients against a small autograd framework (like PyTorch) during development, and mention the importance of caching intermediate activations to avoid recomputation in the backward pass.

1. Clarify the problem and set up notation

Define the chain of matrix multiplications, e.g., Z1 = X @ W1, Z2 = Z1 @ W2, and a scalar loss L. State that you need gradients of L w.r.t. all inputs and parameters.

2. Derive gradients using the chain rule

For each operation, derive the local gradients: for Z = A @ B, dL/dA = dL/dZ @ B^T and dL/dB = A^T @ dL/dZ. Then propagate backward through the chain.

3. Implement forward pass with caching

Compute and store intermediate matrices (e.g., Z1, Z2) during the forward pass so they can be reused in the backward pass, saving computation.

4. Implement backward pass step by step

Starting from the gradient of the loss w.r.t. the final output, apply the derived formulas in reverse order to compute gradients for each parameter and input.

5. Validate and discuss trade-offs

Mention numerical gradient checking or comparison with autograd, and discuss memory vs. recomputation trade-offs (e.g., checkpointing).

Key Points to Mention

  • Chain rule for matrix multiplication: dL/dA = dL/dZ @ B^T, dL/dB = A^T @ dL/dZ
  • Importance of caching intermediate activations to avoid recomputation
  • Shape consistency: ensure gradients match the shapes of the corresponding forward variables
  • Vectorization: implement using matrix operations, not loops, for efficiency
  • Memory vs. computation trade-off: storing activations vs. recomputing them
  • Verification: compare manual gradients with autograd or numerical gradient checking

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.

Q4

Implement both the forward and backward passes for the matrix chain product using a Hillis-Steele parallel prefix scan pattern.

Algorithms & Data StructuresSystem DesignTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

Did not see this coming.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

First, clarify the problem: matrix chain multiplication is associative, so we can compute the product in any order, and the goal is to find the optimal parenthesization that minimizes scalar multiplications. Then, explain that the Hillis-Steele parallel prefix scan pattern can be adapted to compute the dynamic programming table for the optimal cost and the split points, using a parallel reduction over the chain length. Finally, describe how to implement the forward pass (computing costs) and backward pass (reconstructing the optimal parenthesization) using parallel primitives, and discuss trade-offs like work efficiency and memory usage.

Pro tip: Emphasize that while the Hillis-Steele scan is work-inefficient (O(n log n) work), it is step-efficient (O(log n) steps) and can be beneficial for large chains on parallel hardware; also mention that the backward pass can be parallelized by propagating split points or using a parallel tree traversal.

1. Clarify the problem and constraints

Restate the matrix chain multiplication problem: given a sequence of matrices, find the optimal parenthesization to minimize scalar multiplications. Mention that the standard DP solution is O(n^3) sequential, and the goal is to parallelize it using a Hillis-Steele prefix scan pattern.

2. Explain the Hillis-Steele prefix scan pattern

Describe the Hillis-Steele scan: an inclusive scan that computes prefix sums in O(log n) steps using O(n log n) work. Explain how it can be generalized to any associative operation, and how it can be applied to the matrix chain DP by treating the cost computation as a reduction over intervals.

3. Design the forward pass (cost computation)

Show how to compute the DP table m[i][j] (minimum cost) in parallel. For each length L from 2 to n, compute all intervals of length L in parallel using a scan over the split points k. Use the associative operation: m[i][j] = min_{i<=k<j} (m[i][k] + m[k+1][j] + p_{i-1} p_k p_j). Explain how to parallelize the min-reduction over k using a parallel prefix scan or a parallel reduction.

4. Design the backward pass (parenthesization reconstruction)

After computing the optimal costs, reconstruct the optimal parenthesization by storing the split points s[i][j] during the forward pass. In the backward pass, recursively split the chain using s[i][j]. Parallelize this by traversing the split tree in parallel or by using a parallel prefix scan to propagate the splits.

5. Analyze trade-offs and optimizations

Discuss the trade-offs: the Hillis-Steele scan has O(n log n) work but O(log n) depth, which may be beneficial for large n on GPUs. Mention memory usage (O(n^2) for DP table) and possible optimizations like blocking or using a more work-efficient scan (Blelloch) if needed. Also note that the backward pass can be done sequentially in O(n) time, which is negligible compared to the forward pass.

Key Points to Mention

  • Matrix chain multiplication is associative, allowing flexible parenthesization.
  • Standard DP solution is O(n^3) time and O(n^2) space; parallelization aims to reduce depth.
  • Hillis-Steele scan is a parallel prefix sum algorithm with O(log n) depth and O(n log n) work.
  • The DP recurrence can be computed in parallel by increasing interval length, using parallel reductions over split points.
  • Backward pass reconstructs the optimal parenthesization using stored split points; can be parallelized via tree traversal.
  • Trade-offs: work efficiency vs. step efficiency; memory bandwidth and synchronization overhead in parallel implementations.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.