← Maven Securities Interview Insights

Maven Securities·Software Engineer·Technical Phone Screen·Intermediate

Intermediate
May 2026

Summary

Interviewed for a quant role at Mavensecurities and got hit with a probability/expected value problem about horse race betting. Pretty clean problem once you slow down and actually do the math, but the pressure of doing it live made me second-guess myself more than I should have.

Questions Asked (1)

Q1

A horse race has 5 equally-matched horses. You can bet on the finishing order of the top horses. Which of these options gives the highest expected value: (a) $10 bet on all 5 horses in order, pays $1000; (b) $20 bet on top 4 in order, pays $1000; (c) $30 bet on top 3 in order, pays $1000; (d) $60 bet on top 2 in order, pays $1000; (e) walk away with $10 guaranteed.

Algorithms & Data StructuresTechnical Trade-offs
Author's notes

I started by computing the number of ordered arrangements for each case.

Create a free account to read the full note

AI HintsAI Generated

Suggested Approach

Start by clarifying that 'equally-matched' means all 120 finishing orders are equally likely. Then compute the probability of winning for each bet (1/120, 1/24, 1/6, 1/2) and the expected value as (probability × payout) minus the cost. Compare the results and also consider the guaranteed $10 option.

Pro tip: Mention that in real-world trading, expected value is not the only consideration—risk tolerance and variance matter. However, for this question, the expected value calculation clearly favors option (d), so you should confidently state that while acknowledging the risk.

1. Clarify assumptions

Confirm that 'equally-matched' implies each of the 5! = 120 possible finishing orders is equally likely. State that payouts are total returns, not profits.

2. Compute win probabilities

For each bet, determine the number of favorable outcomes: (a) 1/120, (b) 1/24, (c) 1/6, (d) 1/2. Explain that these are the probabilities of the specified top horses finishing in the exact order.

3. Calculate expected values

For each option, compute EV = (probability × payout) − cost. For (a): (1/120)*1000 − 10 = −1.67; (b): (1/24)*1000 − 20 = 21.67; (c): (1/6)*1000 − 30 = 136.67; (d): (1/2)*1000 − 60 = 440; (e): 10.

4. Compare and conclude

Identify that option (d) has the highest expected value ($440), followed by (c) ($136.67), then (b) ($21.67), then (e) ($10), and (a) is negative. State that (d) is the best choice based on expected value.

5. Discuss practical considerations

Acknowledge that option (d) has a 50% chance of losing the entire $60, which might be too risky for some. Mention that in a real trading context, risk-adjusted returns or utility functions might be used, but for this puzzle, EV is the metric.

Key Points to Mention

  • Equally-matched horses imply uniform distribution over all permutations.
  • Probability of correctly predicting top k horses in order is 1/(5Pk) = (5-k)!/5!.
  • Expected value formula: EV = (probability of winning × payout) − cost.
  • Option (d) yields the highest EV of $440.
  • Option (a) has negative EV, so it's worse than walking away.
  • In practice, consider risk tolerance and variance, not just EV.

AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.