← ByteDance Interview InsightsSoftware Engineer
I went with counter plus base62 encoding first because it's predictable and collision-free, then they pushed me on what happens when the counter resets or you're running multiple nodes.
Start by clarifying requirements (scale, read/write ratio, custom aliases, expiration) and then propose a short-code generation strategy (e.g., base62 encoding of a globally unique ID). Implement a simple in-memory version using a hash map for storage and a counter or random generator for IDs, and discuss trade-offs like collision handling and scalability.
Pro tip: Mention that using a globally unique ID generator (like Snowflake) avoids collisions and allows predictable short codes, but consider the trade-off of exposing sequential IDs; alternatively, use a hash with collision resolution. Also, discuss how to handle concurrent writes and reads.
Ask about expected scale (e.g., 100M URLs), read/write ratio, latency requirements, custom aliases, expiration, and analytics. This shows you think about real-world constraints.
Propose a strategy: either base62 encoding of a unique ID (from a counter or distributed ID generator) or hashing the URL and taking a substring. Discuss collision handling and length trade-offs.
Write a simple class with a hash map for storage and a counter for ID generation. Implement encode (generate short code, store mapping) and decode (lookup original URL).
Talk about limitations of in-memory (persistence, scalability) and how to extend to distributed systems (e.g., database, caching, sharding). Mention collision probability and mitigation.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
Talked through retry-on-collision with a random generator, then appending a suffix to the input before rehashing.
Start by clarifying the requirements and scale of the URL shortening system, then explain how hash collisions can occur and present multiple strategies to handle them, such as open addressing, chaining, or using a unique ID generator. Compare the trade-offs of each approach in terms of performance, complexity, and scalability, and conclude with a recommendation based on the system's constraints.
Pro tip: Mention that collisions can be avoided altogether by using a distributed unique ID generator (like Snowflake) and then encoding the ID in base62, which is a common approach in large-scale systems like Bytedance's. This shows you think beyond just handling collisions to preventing them.
Ask about the expected number of URLs, read/write ratio, latency requirements, and whether the short URL length is fixed. This determines the collision probability and acceptable trade-offs.
Describe approaches like open addressing (linear probing, quadratic probing), separate chaining, and using a unique ID generator with base62 encoding. Mention that collisions can also be resolved by appending a counter or rehashing.
Compare strategies on metrics like lookup time, memory usage, implementation complexity, and scalability. For example, open addressing has better cache performance but is sensitive to load factor, while chaining is simpler but uses more memory.
Discuss how collisions are handled in a distributed system, such as using consistent hashing or a centralized ID generator. Mention that distributed ID generators (e.g., Snowflake) can eliminate collisions by design.
Based on the requirements, recommend a specific approach (e.g., unique ID generator + base62) and justify why it's suitable for the given scale and constraints.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
Start by clarifying the service's requirements—scale, latency, durability, and data sharing needs—then compare in-memory dictionaries and Redis across those dimensions. Conclude with concrete scenarios where each option is the better fit, showing you can make pragmatic trade-offs.
Pro tip: Mention that in-memory dictionaries are often the right choice for single-instance, read-heavy caches with no persistence needs, while Redis shines when you need shared state, persistence, or advanced data structures—but always consider operational overhead.
Ask about scale (data size, QPS), latency targets, durability, and whether multiple instances need to share state. This ensures your comparison is grounded in the actual use case.
Evaluate in-memory dictionary vs. Redis on performance, scalability, persistence, data structures, and operational complexity. Highlight that in-memory is fastest but limited to a single process, while Redis adds network overhead but offers rich features.
Map each option to concrete scenarios: in-memory for local caching, session data in a single server, or temporary computations; Redis for distributed caching, shared sessions, rate limiting, pub/sub, and persistent stores.
Discuss that in-memory can be used as a first-level cache with Redis as a second-level cache, and mention that Redis can be overkill for small-scale services. Show awareness of cost and complexity.
Based on the clarified requirements, state which option you would choose and why, or propose a hybrid solution. This demonstrates decisiveness and practical judgment.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
Redis makes this almost free with the EXPIRE command, so I led with that.
Start by clarifying requirements: per-URL TTL means each short URL can have a custom expiration time, and expired URLs should return 410 Gone or redirect to a default page. Then propose a design that stores expiration metadata alongside the URL mapping and handles expiration at read time and via background cleanup.
Pro tip: Mention that you would use lazy deletion on read combined with a periodic background job to avoid expensive scans, and that you'd add a 'ttl' field to the URL record with a default value for backward compatibility.
Ask whether TTL is set at creation time only or can be updated later, and whether expired URLs should be deleted or just return an error. Also consider if there's a default TTL for URLs without one.
Add an expiration timestamp field to the URL mapping record. Consider using a separate table or index for efficient querying of expired URLs, and decide on a storage engine that supports TTL natively (e.g., Redis with EXPIRE, DynamoDB TTL).
When a short URL is accessed, check if the current time exceeds the expiration timestamp. If expired, return HTTP 410 Gone (or 404) and optionally trigger asynchronous deletion.
Use a scheduled job or a queue-based system to periodically scan for and delete expired URLs. For large scale, use a distributed lock or sharding to avoid contention.
Update the API to accept an optional TTL parameter (e.g., in seconds or as an absolute timestamp). Ensure backward compatibility and document the behavior for expired URLs.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.