Start by systematically comparing the two kernels across the five dimensions, using concrete examples and reasoning about hardware behavior. Then, for a given workload, justify your preference based on matrix shape and performance characteristics, and propose further optimizations like vectorization, tiling, or using shared memory for reuse.
Pro tip: Quantify the impact of memory coalescing and occupancy on performance, and mention how matrix shape (e.g., very wide vs. very tall) affects the choice between 1D and 2D thread indexing.
Compare how threads and blocks are organized: 1D vs. 2D indexing, block dimensions, and how they map to matrix elements. Discuss implications for occupancy and boundary handling.
Assess coalescing of global memory accesses, use of vectorized loads/stores, and whether accesses are contiguous. Explain how each kernel's pattern affects bandwidth utilization.
Determine if shared memory is used, and if so, how it's utilized (e.g., for tiling or staging). Discuss whether it's beneficial for element-wise addition, which has no data reuse.
Describe how each kernel handles out-of-bounds accesses (e.g., conditional checks, padding). Discuss performance overhead and correctness implications.
Reason about performance for different matrix shapes (square, tall, wide) and sizes. Recommend a preferred kernel for a given workload and suggest further optimizations like vectorization, loop unrolling, or using multiple elements per thread.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.