← Adobe Interview InsightsSoftware Engineer
Started with hash-set, which they expected.
Start by clarifying constraints (e.g., array size, value range, memory limits) and then present multiple approaches: brute force, sorting, hash set, and in-place marking (if values are within 1..n). Compare time/space trade-offs and discuss which is optimal for given constraints. Conclude with a recommended solution and mention edge cases.
Pro tip: At Adobe, interviewers value practical trade-off analysis; explicitly discuss when the in-place marking approach is applicable (e.g., values in range 1..n) and its limitations, showing you consider real-world constraints.
Ask about array size, value range, whether the array can be modified, and memory constraints. This determines which approaches are feasible.
Mention O(n^2) brute force and O(n log n) sorting approaches, noting their simplicity but inefficiency for large inputs.
Explain using a hash set to track seen numbers, achieving O(n) time but O(n) extra space. Highlight its simplicity and general applicability.
If values are in range 1..n, use index marking (negation or adding n) to find duplicates in O(n) time and O(1) extra space. Explain the algorithm and its constraints.
Summarize trade-offs and recommend the best approach based on constraints. Mention edge cases like multiple duplicates, no duplicates, and large arrays.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.
Start by acknowledging that the bounded range (1-200) allows trading space for time or using the array itself as a hash table. Then compare bitmask, counting array, and in-place marking in terms of time/space complexity, mutation, and practical trade-offs, and recommend the most suitable approach based on constraints like memory limits and whether the input can be modified.
Pro tip: Mention that in-place marking is often preferred in memory-constrained environments, but it mutates the input and can be error-prone; always clarify with the interviewer whether mutation is allowed and whether the range is inclusive.
Ask whether the array can be modified, if extra space is allowed, and what the exact range is (inclusive of 200). This determines which approaches are viable.
Use a bitmask of size 200 bits (e.g., 4 64-bit integers) to track presence. It uses O(1) space (constant, ~25 bytes) and O(n) time, but only works for presence/absence, not counts.
Allocate an array of size 200 (or 201) to count frequencies. It uses O(1) space (constant, ~800 bytes) and O(n) time, and supports frequency queries, but requires extra space.
Use the array itself to mark visited indices by negating or adding an offset (e.g., add 200). It uses O(1) extra space and O(n) time, but mutates the input and requires careful handling to avoid overwriting.
Summarize trade-offs: bitmask is most space-efficient but limited to presence; counting array is simple and supports counts; in-place marking saves space but mutates input. Recommend based on constraints (e.g., if mutation allowed and memory tight, use in-place; if counts needed, use counting array).
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.