This question has a lot of surface area and I think I underestimated that.
Start by clarifying functional and non-functional requirements, such as the rate limit rules, scale, and consistency needs. Then compare algorithm choices (token bucket, sliding window, etc.) and justify your selection based on trade-offs. Finally, detail the storage layer, failure handling, and how to communicate limit status to clients via headers and error responses.
Pro tip: Emphasize that rate limiting is often implemented at multiple layers (e.g., API gateway, service mesh, application) and discuss how to avoid double-counting or conflicting limits. Also, mention the importance of monitoring and alerting on rate limiter effectiveness to catch misconfigurations.
Ask about the expected scale (requests per second, number of clients), the granularity of limits (per user, IP, API key), and whether the system needs to be distributed. Also determine if strict enforcement or eventual consistency is acceptable.
Compare algorithms like fixed window, sliding window log, sliding window counter, token bucket, and leaky bucket. Discuss their pros and cons in terms of memory usage, accuracy, and burst handling, and select one that fits the requirements.
Decide on a storage solution (e.g., Redis, in-memory with sync, or a database) that supports the chosen algorithm. Address how to handle distributed counters, atomic operations, and data consistency across multiple nodes.
Plan for failures: what happens if the storage is unavailable? Should you fail open or closed? Discuss fallback strategies, such as local rate limiting or degraded modes, and how to handle clock skew in distributed systems.
Describe how to surface limit information: include headers like X-RateLimit-Limit, X-RateLimit-Remaining, X-RateLimit-Reset, and Retry-After. Also, return appropriate HTTP status codes (429 Too Many Requests) and consider providing a way for clients to query their limits.
AI-generated suggestions, not part of the candidate's original notes. May be inaccurate — verify before relying on them.